Get Your Weekly Digest

Receive the best podcast summaries and insights delivered to your inbox every week.

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe anytime.

We Study Billionaires - The Investor’s Podcast Network

TIP768: Best Quality Stock Idea Q4 2025 w/ Clay Finck

Published November 14, 2025
Visit Podcast Website

About This Episode

Host Clay Finck presents Interactive Brokers (IBKR) as his quarterly best quality stock idea, analyzing its business model, economics, and long‑term growth prospects. He covers the firm's history and founder Thomas Pederphy's automation-focused culture, its revenue drivers like commissions and net interest income, and its unique low-cost, tech-heavy positioning versus competitors such as Charles Schwab and Robinhood. The episode also explores IBKR's competitive advantages, management incentives, valuation, key risks, and why Clay holds a 2% personal position in the stock.

Topics Covered

Investing Capital allocation Entrepreneurship Innovation strategy Crypto Online brokerage Automation Stock market valuation Financial technology Competitive advantage

Disclaimer: We provide independent summaries of podcasts and are not affiliated with or endorsed in any way by any podcast or creator. All podcast names and content are the property of their respective owners. The views and opinions expressed within the podcasts belong solely to the original hosts and guests and do not reflect the views or positions of Summapod.

Quick Takeaways

  • Interactive Brokers has grown client accounts from 200,000 in 2012 to over 4 million, with recent account growth around 30-36% per year and client equity rising to over $750 billion.
  • Despite positioning itself as a low-cost provider, IBKR generates exceptional profitability, with gross margins around 82% and pre-tax margins about 75%, rivaling top technology companies.
  • Founder Thomas Pederphy built the firm on an obsession with automation and direct market access, enabling low fees, highly efficient operations, and a durable moat that rivals struggle to match.
  • More than half of IBKR's revenue comes from net interest income on customer cash and margin loans, making interest rates and client risk appetite important, though partially offset by growing assets and accounts.
  • The company targets sophisticated traders, hedge funds, and institutions globally, while still serving retail investors and expanding offerings such as IBKR Lite, crypto trading, securities lending, and white-label infrastructure.
  • Clay views management as highly aligned owner-operators, with Pederphy owning nearly 70% of the business, no long-term debt on the balance sheet, and a culture that prioritizes technology over sales and marketing.
  • He sees meaningful international growth potential and a clear path to 20+ million accounts, but notes cyclical exposure to markets and key person risk related to the 81-year-old founder.
  • Clay considers the current valuation (around 31x trailing earnings) his least favorite aspect but still expects earnings to grow at least 15% annually over time, so he initiated a 2% portfolio position.

Podcast Notes

Episode introduction and framing of the Best Quality Ideas series

Purpose of the Best Quality Ideas series

Each quarter the series breaks down a quality stock's business model, competitive advantages, valuation, and more[0:02]
This quarter's featured company is Interactive Brokers (ticker IBKR)[0:11]

High-level snapshot of Interactive Brokers

IBKR is a global online brokerage giving investors access to markets worldwide with industry-low costs in stocks, options, futures, currencies, and more[0:20]
It serves over 4 million accounts across more than 200 countries and territories[0:27]
It is a go-to choice for professional traders, hedge funds, and sophisticated investors seeking global market access[0:33]
Over the past decade, IBKR shares have compounded at 21% per year versus 14.9% for the S&P 500[0:39]

Key questions and themes Clay will cover

Why Clay believes IBKR can grow accounts from 4 million to over 20 million[0:54]
Story of founder Thomas Pederphy coming to America with nothing and building an ~$80 billion personal fortune[0:57]
How IBKR operates as a low-cost provider yet has better margin profiles than Visa and Meta[1:10]
How focus on automation and technology creates a durable moat competitors struggle to rival[1:12]
Discussion of valuation, risks, and why Clay added IBKR to his portfolio[1:18]

Host introduction, disclosures, and personal stake

Host and series context

Clay introduces himself as host of The Investors Podcast and frames this as the quarterly Best Quality Idea episode[1:57]
He confirms that this episode covers Interactive Brokers[1:31]

Disclaimers and conflict of interest disclosure

TIP is not receiving any compensation to talk about Interactive Brokers, and IBKR is not a sponsor as of the air date[2:23]
Clay is a very happy customer of IBKR's brokerage product[2:27]
During research for the episode he decided to buy shares for his own portfolio at around $71 per share[2:39]
He emphasizes that listeners should do their own research and not treat the episode as a buy or sell recommendation[2:44]

Clay's personal experience with IBKR and initial investment lens

Peter Lynch's "buy what you know" idea and Clay's application

Clay references Peter Lynch's philosophy of buying what you know and leveraging insights from everyday product use[2:57]
He notes that liking a product is a starting clue for research, not a complete investment formula[3:36]

Clay's move to Interactive Brokers and observed switching costs

In early 2023, Clay moved all brokerage and retirement accounts from his previous broker to Interactive Brokers[3:21]
He wishes he had bought IBKR stock the day he moved because the stock has performed very well since[3:27]
His primary reason for switching was wanting affordable access to international markets[3:45]
• He cites IBKR's wide access to markets in Japan, Europe, Canada, and broadly worldwide
He found that previous brokers made accessing international markets difficult and switching to a new broker painful[4:16]
• His prior broker charged fees and did not make transfers easy; it took multiple calls, emails, and a few weeks to complete the move
The difficulty of switching highlighted meaningful switching costs in brokerage relationships, which can advantage a superior platform like IBKR[4:33]

High-level business and stock overview

Ownership by notable investors and prior coverage

IBKR has been on Clay's radar since he moved his accounts[4:49]
The stock was discussed on the show about two years ago with Jonathan Boyer in episode 599[4:56]
Brian Lawrence of Oak Cliff Capital holds IBKR as his top reported position at over 25% of his fund (excluding unreported international holdings)[5:08]
Lawrence has been featured on the show multiple times, and Rob Vinal of RV Capital also holds a sizable IBKR position built largely in Q1 and Q2 2023[5:26]

Market cap, growth, and competitive context

IBKR's true market cap is just under $120 billion[5:38]
Over the past decade, the stock has compounded at roughly 21% per year, excluding dividends[5:38]
Some data providers show a $30 billion market cap by backing out IBG Holdings LLC's 75.2% ownership; Clay clarifies the consolidated business is around $119-120 billion[6:02]
Total accounts have grown 20x since 2012, from 200,000 to over 4 million[6:26]
• By comparison, Fidelity has over 50 million accounts, Charles Schwab 37 million, and Robinhood 25 million, so IBKR still has a relatively small share
Year-over-year account growth is about 32%[6:42]
Client asset value on the platform grew from $32 billion in 2012 to over $750 billion today[6:56]

Surprisingly strong margins for a "commodity" industry

Clay initially assumed discount brokerage was a fiercely competitive, quasi-commodity business with low margins and volatile earnings[7:18]
IBKR instead has consistently strong earnings growth and exceptional margins[7:31]
• Gross margins are about 82%, and pre‑tax margins are around 75%, higher than Visa, Nvidia, and Meta
From a margin and growth profile, IBKR looks more like a SaaS or technology business than a traditional broker[7:56]

Founder Thomas Pederphy: ownership, philosophy, and background

Ownership stake and wealth

IBKR was founded by Thomas Pederphy in 1978, and he stepped down as CEO in 2019 after decades of involvement[8:04]
He owns nearly 70% of the shares, valuing his stake at around $80 billion[8:15]
According to Forbes, this makes him the 24th wealthiest person in the world at age 81[8:23]

Personality and business philosophy

Clay notes Pederphy is blunt and straightforward in interviews[8:40]
When asked about his success, Pederphy said business is very simple and is about trying to give customers a better future[8:54]
Clay believes this simple idea explains IBKR's persistent share gains and customer growth[8:56]
Clay cites himself as an example of a customer who felt compelled to switch because IBKR's offering was compelling[9:17]

Early life in Hungary and motivation to emigrate

Pederphy was born in Hungary in 1944 near the end of World War II and grew up under communism[15:18]
His family lost land after World War I and their remaining assets to the communist state after World War II[15:25]
His father fled the country when he was two after divorcing his mother[15:36]
As a child he once found his mother crying because she feared they would starve due to lack of stable employment[15:47]
Despite limited access to books, he obtained a few classics and learned about capitalism from them[15:59]
• He observed that state ownership in socialism meant people were not rewarded for hard work or new ideas, so they lacked both, leading to very low living standards
Seeing the Statue of Liberty on US stamps made him want to move to America; he called it an excellent marketing ploy by the US[16:30]

Immigration to the US and early career

At age 21 in 1965 he obtained a one-way ticket to New York[16:42]
He did not speak English on arrival and learned computer programming before learning English[16:54]
By 1977, he had saved $200,000 and bought a seat on the American Stock Exchange for $36,000[17:09]
He traded options using his own valuation models and once lost $75,000 on a single trade, which he attributed to insider trading[17:24]
That loss taught him to always hedge trades in case things moved against him[17:32]

Timber Hill, early automation, and market making

He rebuilt capital mathematically, hired others to execute trades, and exploited market inefficiencies[17:42]
By 1982 his operation was called Timber Hill and was very profitable[17:47]
He developed handheld devices providing data clerks needed for profitable trades[17:58]
When they tried to enter the Chicago Board Options Exchange, a rule was passed banning analytical devices on the floor[18:05]
Exchanges made it hard for his team to trade profitably in real time, but they could not stop him from innovating around the rules[18:24]
In 1987 he achieved his goal of building the first fully automated trading system in Wall Street history[18:43]
• His machines executed trades without human intervention; NASDAQ employees were shocked to see a computer placing orders with no human present
• NASDAQ later discovered he had hijacked the terminal's data line to feed his automated system
When NASDAQ insisted trades must be entered via keyboard like everyone else, he built a machine that automatically typed on the keyboard for a person[19:26]
Clay notes that automating everything is in Pederphy's DNA and carries through to how Interactive Brokers operates today[19:43]
He started a market making business in 1993 that expanded from US cities to Frankfurt, London, and Hong Kong[19:48]
Goldman Sachs made multiple offers to buy the market maker, but he declined and instead set out to build a platform giving ordinary investors the same tech advantages he had[20:00]
That platform became Interactive Brokers[20:13]

Wall Street's eventual adoption

In the 1990s, the financial landscape remained overwhelming for many, and he was ahead of his time[20:21]
Eventually, Wall Street embraced his innovations, and Interactive Brokers became the broker of choice for many professional traders[20:30]

Evolution of Interactive Brokers' business model

IPO and shift from options to brokerage

IBKR went public in May 2007[24:30]
At IPO, its options division Timber Hill still generated over 80% of company revenue, making it mostly a trading business rather than a pure brokerage[24:00]
Early stock performance was not great partly because the options division was in decline while brokerage was growing[24:23]
The company did not need to go public financially; Pederphy mainly wanted brand visibility and disliked spending on advertising[24:39]
He chose a Dutch auction IPO, saving about $80 million in banker fees while selling 10% of his business[25:29]
The Dutch auction meant no roadshow and limited Wall Street attention, so IBKR remained underfollowed[25:41]

Closing Timber Hill and focusing on brokerage

In 2017, IBKR shut down Timber Hill as the brokerage business required more focus and the earlier advantages in options market making had disappeared[25:53]
Clay views this as evidence of long-term thinking-willingness to let go of declining profit pools to focus on enduring segments[26:31]

Culture of automation and focus on technology

IBKR's intense focus on automation and low fees has made it the broker of choice for many hedge funds and professional traders who appreciate trading costs[26:53]
In a 2014 quote, Pederphy said he has always been a computer programmer, surrounded himself with programmers, and focuses on building technology rather than sales[27:31]
• He stated that automating everything and everyone lets IBKR operate at much lower cost and charge very low commissions; he called automation the "magic" behind the business

Launch of IBKR Lite to broaden appeal

In 2019, IBKR launched IBKR Lite aimed at long-term buy-and-hold investors rather than active traders[28:00]
IBKR Lite offers unlimited commission-free trading on US exchange-listed stocks and ETFs, no account minimums, and no inactivity fees[28:10]
IBKR Lite uses payment for order flow (PFOF), while IBKR Pro does not[28:33]
Clay sees IBKR Lite as a long-term investment in expanding the customer base, even if near-term returns are modest[29:01]

Management succession and evolving view on marketing

In 2019, long-time executive Milan Galic, who joined in 1990, became CEO[29:25]
Pederphy remains deeply involved, especially in sales and marketing, and enjoys solving new problems[29:34]
He has realized he was wrong in assuming marketing is entirely wasteful and may increase marketing spend over time[29:15]

Business model and revenue streams

Core brokerage offering and target customers

IBKR is an online brokerage providing electronic market access to stocks, options, futures, currencies, commodities, crypto, and more[9:30]
The firm aims to offer a comprehensive range of instruments and global markets with the lowest trading commissions, attractive margin loan rates, and competitive interest on deposits[9:51]
IBKR's core customer base consists of professional and institutional traders, hedge funds, proprietary trading firms, and high-net-worth individuals who value global access, low margin rates, and precise execution[13:55]
IBKR is primarily an institutional-grade platform but is also available to retail investors like Clay[14:45]
Clay notes the user interface is not as slick as platforms like Robinhood because the company is run by software developers focused on completeness and efficiency over design[14:10]

Commission structure and PFOF vs direct routing

Clay explains that zero-commission trading at competitors does not mean trading is truly free due to payment for order flow[10:10]
Many brokers route customer orders to market makers like Citadel or Virtu in exchange for payments, potentially sacrificing best execution for customers[10:30]
He describes how small price inefficiencies (fractions of a cent) can add up over time, especially for active traders or large orders[10:50]
Example: a 100-share Google trade on Robinhood would likely be routed to a market maker that prioritizes its own profit, and Robinhood is estimated to have made well over $1.5 billion from PFOF in 2024[11:37]
IBKR Pro does not rely on PFOF; instead, it uses its own smart order router to connect directly to dozens of exchanges and dark pools worldwide, seeking the best available prices in real time[12:13]
IBKR Lite, launched later, does use PFOF for that customer segment[12:25]
IBKR charges commissions but they are often small relative to the savings from better execution and tighter spreads, and customers can choose between tiered or fixed pricing structures[12:36]

Revenue breakdown: commissions, net interest income, and other fees

IBKR earns commissions on trades, comprising around one-third of revenue[29:55]
Net interest income represents over half of revenue and includes interest on customer cash and margin loans[30:05]
• IBKR Pro users earn interest on cash at the federal funds rate minus 0.5%, with a $10,000 minimum cash balance to start earning interest
• IBKR keeps part of the interest earned on customer cash and passes the rest to customers
Other revenue sources include market data fees, PFOF (for Lite), risk exposure fees, and other income, which together are less than 10% of revenue[30:49]

Interest income, margin loans, and rate sensitivity

Net interest income has grown significantly alongside client assets on the platform[30:02]
Margin loan balances are at an all-time high, and Pederphy has noted that a sudden market dislocation would likely reduce risk-taking and margin levels[32:17]
IBKR's margin rates are materially lower than many competitors-around 5% versus roughly 10-11% at E-Trade, Fidelity, Schwab, and Vanguard (depending on margin size)[32:37]
The company's automation allows automatic margin calls and liquidations when collateral is insufficient, reducing operational risk[33:01]
Net interest income is extremely high margin and has become a larger share of the overall business[33:18]
Clay notes investor concern about falling interest rates but emphasizes that IBKR's spread (Fed funds minus 0.5%) remains constant; the bigger impact is on client behavior regarding cash and leverage[33:20]
If the federal funds rate falls to around 2% or lower, Clay believes it could significantly pressure net interest income due to lower cash balances, though cheaper borrowing could partially offset via higher margin usage[35:05]
He highlights cyclical risk: IBKR tends to do very well when markets are volatile and rising, and face headwinds when markets fall, though growing customer numbers should drive long‑term revenue growth[35:46]

Securities lending program

IBKR operates a Securities Lending Program where investors can lend their shares (often to short sellers) in exchange for interest income[36:07]
IBKR automatically matches borrowers with long holders, and the income from the stock loan is shared between IBKR and the investor[36:29]
Investors continue to receive price appreciation and dividends while earning incremental lending income, though rates are often low enough that many may not find it worthwhile[36:43]

Crypto trading and white-label services

IBKR introduced crypto trading in 2021, despite Pederphy himself not being enthusiastic about cryptocurrencies[37:25]
Clay notes that Pederphy listens to customers: if clients want a financial product and IBKR can automate and provide it, they will add it[37:14]
Compared to Coinbase's 100+ million verified accounts and over 250 supported coins, IBKR offers lower fees but only around the top 12 coins[37:28]
In a recent quarter, crypto trading volumes on IBKR were up 87% quarter-over-quarter and 5x year-over-year[37:59]
IBKR also offers a white-label solution that allows banks, hedge funds, and financial advisors to build branded trading platforms on IBKR's global infrastructure[38:05]

Competitive positioning, moat, and customer base dynamics

IBKR as a tech-enabled low-cost provider

Clay argues that IBKR's combination of low trading costs, low margin rates, and high interest on cash, all delivered via automated direct market access, is very hard for competitors to match[38:33]
Many competitors like Schwab, Fidelity, and Morgan Stanley focus more on wealth management and relationships than on being the most efficient, lowest-cost execution venue[38:41]
Due to its tech focus and 75% pre-tax profit margins, Clay views IBKR more like a technology company than a traditional financial services firm[38:55]

Account growth, marketing approach, and referrals

IBKR has over 4.1 million accounts and does not break down accounts by region[39:43]
Over the five years leading up to 2024, accounts grew at 36% per year[39:48]
IBKR spends very little on advertising-SG&A (including advertising) is only about 5% of revenue[40:07]
Clay interprets low marketing spend plus high growth as evidence of a superior product pulling in customers, versus typical push marketing[40:21]
IBKR has an attractive referral program where referrers earn $200 and new customers can receive up to $1,000 in IBKR stock[40:36]
Clay, as a fan of the platform, has referred several friends and family members[40:51]

Customer sophistication vs retail traders

Clay describes a joke about platforms like Robinhood attracting retail traders who follow the 90‑90‑90 principle (90% of value lost in 90 days by 90% of traders), while acknowledging reality is likely not that extreme[41:23]
He believes many Robinhood users trade too frequently without a sound philosophy and may not stay long if they lose money[41:30]
Investors who succeed and gain sophistication are more likely to "graduate" to platforms like IBKR that offer more comprehensive tools and lower all-in costs[41:36]
IBKR attracts a more sophisticated investor base that tends to make money over time and understands trading costs, which matters more as account balances and stakes grow[41:58]
Clay notes that IBKR also gets some gambler-type users, and investor types on any platform are a spectrum rather than purely one segment[43:06]

Platform usability and customer support weaknesses

The platform is designed by developers, and Clay concedes the interface is not great and may turn off some retail investors who test it[42:39]
Customer support is not IBKR's strong suit; support appears more focused on onboarding new customers than helping existing ones[43:27]
Clay personally had no major issues during his 2023 account move, and since onboarding he has not needed support due to simple usage (no margin, securities lending, or complex trades)[43:35]
A Mastermind member in Dubai who manages client assets has used IBKR for over a decade and appreciates its broad global market access[44:19]
Another member in the US managing a fund focused on Asia uses Goldman Sachs as broker because IBKR lacks access to every Asian market he needs[44:33]
Clay concludes that IBKR doesn't offer everything competitors do but covers a lot of what many customers need and continues to expand its reach[45:00]

Moat analysis using the "Seven Powers" framework

Clay references Hamilton Helmer's book "Seven Powers" and uses it to frame IBKR's competitive advantages[45:12]
He highlights several powers relevant to IBKR: scale economies, counter-positioning, switching costs, limited branding, and strong process power[45:12]
Scale economies allow IBKR to earn higher returns than competitors; rivals would either have to disrupt their own economics or scale significantly to match[45:27]

Counter-positioning vs incumbents like Charles Schwab

Counter-positioning: IBKR's low-cost model undercuts prime brokers; incumbents would have to sacrifice existing profit pools to match IBKR's pricing and technology[49:48]
Clay compares IBKR with Charles Schwab, which has 37 million accounts vs. IBKR's ~4 million[50:07]
Schwab's strengths: beginner-friendly, easy-to-use platform, wealth management and advisory services, physical branches, and $0 stock/ETF trading[50:21]
Schwab's weaknesses: higher all-in trading costs, higher margin rates, limited international access, and weaker offering for active or sophisticated traders[50:29]
IBKR's strengths directly map to Schwab's weaknesses: advanced tools, global access, and low all-in costs[50:49]
Clay believes Schwab is unlikely to fully copy IBKR's model because it would require overhauling its offering and cannibalizing its own cash cows, a classic Innovator's Dilemma situation[51:22]

Switching costs, branding, and process power

Switching costs cut both ways: once IBKR wins a client, it's hard for them to leave; but the same applies to competitors' customers[51:48]
Clay notes that IBKR's superior offering is sufficient for many customers to overcome switching friction, as he did[51:56]
Branding plays a role but is less significant; IBKR does little marketing and has mediocre support, which doesn't strongly bolster brand perception[52:17]
Process power is a major advantage: a culture obsessed with cost reduction and automation has created systems and processes that are very hard for competitors to replicate[52:35]

Growth runway, international expansion, and management alignment

Growth potential in US and international markets

Around three-fourths of IBKR's revenue currently comes from the US[53:08]
Pederphy believes there is strong growth potential both in the US and abroad and has set a near-term goal of 20 million accounts, up from about 4 million today[53:18]
Clay looks for companies with a clear path to above-average growth for at least the next five years and believes IBKR qualifies[53:29]
Payment for order flow is mainly a US phenomenon and is banned in many markets, which may give IBKR an advantage internationally where fee-based brokers lack that revenue lever[53:44]
International customers often highly value broad market access, which aligns with IBKR's strengths[54:00]

Management, ownership, and capital allocation

The company remains led by founder-chairman Thomas Pederphy, whom Clay prefers as an owner-operator type[54:24]
Clay notes IBKR was added to the S&P 500 in August 2025, which may increase investor attention[54:58]
Share repurchases are practically nonexistent, likely due to low float caused by Pederphy's large ownership[55:13]
The company pays a very small dividend and appears to focus primarily on reinvesting capital into enhancing offerings, adding new services, and entering new markets[55:30]
On a recent earnings call, the CFO stated IBKR has no long-term debt, firm equity of $19.5 billion up 22% year over year, and a balance sheet designed to support growth and win new business while considering capital allocation[55:42]
During the early-2023 banking crisis, IBKR avoided problems because it held very short-dated bonds (30 days or less) rather than long-duration treasuries that fell sharply in value[56:08]
Since the start of 2020, IBKR's share price is up about 6x while Charles Schwab's is up about 2x, illustrating better navigation of the rate cycle[56:41]
IBKR's conservative balance sheet with no long-term debt leaves room to exploit high-return opportunities, such as attractive acquisitions, in future crises[56:57]

Executive team composition and incentives

IBKR requires all executives to have experience as computer programmers, reinforcing the tech-driven culture[57:24]
CEO Milan Galic joined as a software developer in 1990; CFO Paul Brody joined in 1987 as treasurer; most executives have decade-plus tenure[57:27]
Clay sees long executive tenures as evidence of a strong internal value proposition and healthy culture[57:51]
In 2024, Pederphy earned $750,000 with no stock bonus; his salary is capped at 0.2% of net income per proxy footnotes[58:12]
The CEO earned about $17 million and the CFO about $6 million, which Clay finds reasonable relative to peers like Schwab and Robinhood[58:18]
IBKR grants less stock overall to management than many peers; bonuses are tied to adjusted income before tax, adjusted pre-tax margin, and three-year adjusted net revenue growth[58:50]
This compensation structure aligns management with shareholders on growth, profitability, and efficiency, and non-founder executives' share holdings have been rising over time[58:52]
A potential drawback is that management is largely composed of engineers rather than client-facing leaders; Clay suggests a stronger sales effort might help but notes 32% account growth demonstrates current success[59:14]

Valuation, long-term thesis, and key risks

Current valuation and earnings outlook

As of recording, IBKR's market cap is about $119 billion and net income about $3.7 billion, implying a trailing P/E of roughly 31[59:52]
Clay notes many value investors would find a P/E of 31 high but stresses IBKR's strong growth runway and differentiated business[1:00:03]
In the most recent earnings report, adjusted income before taxes grew by 45%[1:00:22]
He acknowledges IBKR may be slightly over-earning due to recent interest rate levels; the Federal Reserve cut rates by 25 basis points in both September and October, creating some headwind for net interest margins[1:00:39]
However, account growth of 32% and customer equity growth of 40% year over year should help offset interest-related headwinds[1:01:03]
Given IBKR's strong balance sheet and excess capital, Clay argues the market fairly assigns a higher multiple than to a weaker, more leveraged financial company[1:01:12]
He observes that the current P/E is on the high side relative to IBKR's own history (closer to 20), so disappointing quarters could cause multiple compression[1:00:27]
Clay's long-term thesis is that IBKR's superior, differentiated product will drive rapid account growth and at least 15% annual net income growth, with shareholder returns roughly tracking earnings growth over time[1:02:24]

Global tailwinds and optionality

IBKR benefits from global growth in stock investing; studies show broadband access correlates with higher stock market participation[1:02:40]
IBKR has customers in over 200 countries and territories, effectively covering the world[1:02:57]
Pederphy has said IBKR can continue growing accounts at around 30% per year without much advertising[1:03:06]
Clay suggests that if IBKR increases marketing spend, some years could see 40%+ account growth, given the company has ample capital to spend[1:03:23]
He notes IBKR's historical pattern of adding new offerings over time and expects optionality from products not yet conceived[1:03:47]
One recent example is IBKR Forecast Trader, which lets eligible clients trade binary yes/no contracts on events like whether the Fed will cut rates at its next meeting[1:03:57]
Forecast Trader is currently small but could become a meaningful growth contributor; IBKR has stated no current plans to enter sports betting, though Clay leaves open the possibility they could one day disrupt that industry too[1:03:53]

Key risks: cyclicality, leverage, and founder dependence

Economic and market cyclicality: IBKR's revenue is tightly linked to market activity and investor sentiment[1:04:36]
In prolonged downturns or bear markets, trading volumes and risk appetite fall, shrinking commissions and margin income; IBKR's stock tends to move with or more than the broader market[1:04:47]
Clay notes margin loan balances are at an all-time high, signaling elevated risk appetite that could reverse sharply in a downturn[1:04:52]
Client equity on IBKR's platform is highly correlated with overall market levels; a bear market would naturally depress it and pressure revenue[1:05:12]
He points out that in early 2025, IBKR's share price fell nearly 40% during the "tariff tantrum" before recovering to new highs, illustrating volatility investors must tolerate[1:05:34]
Clay also warns that some new clients treat markets like a casino and may have inflated account numbers during good times; when markets fall, these accounts may be wiped out and leave permanently[1:05:47]
Founder/key-person risk: Pederphy is 81, still heavily involved, and has been central to IBKR's culture and strategy[1:06:10]
The company must prove it can maintain execution quality once he exits; Clay views the existing team as strong but does not assume the business will be identical without him[1:06:27]
Pederphy owns over 70% of the shares; while it is not public what happens to his stake upon his death, Clay assumes it likely stays within the family[1:06:36]
He flags risk that heirs might sell down shares, creating sustained selling pressure, or that the market might discount IBKR's value absent its iconic founder[1:06:57]

Clay's portfolio allocation and return expectations

Clay has sized IBKR as a 2% position in his personal portfolio[1:07:06]
The position is large enough to keep him engaged and benefit from potential upside but small enough to leave room to add on significant pullbacks[1:07:12]
He prefers owning companies where he has high conviction the business will be much larger in 5-10 years; IBKR's robust account growth leads him to believe this will be the case[1:07:26]
Account growth is currently around 30%, higher than much of IBKR's history; on the recent earnings call, Pederphy said he expects this high growth to continue for the foreseeable future[1:07:47]
Clay, who is satisfied with consistent 15%+ earnings growth, would like to see account growth remain above 20% for the next five years[1:08:37]
He values investing alongside great business builders and considers Pederphy an unconventional CEO willing to make short-term sacrifices for long-term shareholder benefit[1:10:03]
Clay is optimistic that the team surrounding Pederphy will continue executing well once he eventually hands over the reins[1:10:22]

Episode conclusion and listener engagement

Final thoughts on Interactive Brokers

Clay reiterates that there is a lot to like about IBKR as a business and he is excited to follow its journey as both investor and satisfied customer[1:08:37]

Closing remarks and contact information

Clay thanks listeners for tuning in and hopes they found value in the discussion of IBKR[1:10:11]
He invites feedback or shared notes on the company via email at clay@theinvestorspodcast.com or via LinkedIn[1:10:22]

Lessons Learned

Actionable insights and wisdom you can apply to your business, career, and personal life.

1

A durable competitive advantage often comes from building superior processes and automation that competitors cannot easily copy without cannibalizing their own business models.

Reflection Questions:

  • • Where in your work or business could you invest in automation or process improvements that would materially lower your cost structure over time?
  • • How might competitors be constrained from copying your potential advantages because it would disrupt their existing revenue streams?
  • • What is one process you rely on today that, if fully automated in the next year, would free up significant time or margin for you?
2

Aligning yourself with owner-operators who have substantial skin in the game can improve the odds that decisions are made for long-term value creation rather than short-term optics.

Reflection Questions:

  • • Which of the companies, teams, or projects you are involved with today have leaders whose incentives are clearly tied to long-term outcomes?
  • • How could you better assess whether a leader's compensation and ownership structure truly aligns with your interests before committing capital or time?
  • • What steps could you take this quarter to increase your own skin in the game on a key initiative so your incentives match its long-term success?
3

Switching costs can both protect and limit you: they create moats for businesses you own, but they also lock you into suboptimal tools or relationships if you ignore better alternatives.

Reflection Questions:

  • • In what areas of your life or business are you still using a product or service mainly because switching feels painful, not because it is the best option?
  • • How would you quantify the long-term benefit of moving to a superior platform compared to the one-time friction of switching?
  • • What is one high-friction relationship (vendor, tool, platform) you could deliberately re-evaluate this year to ensure it still deserves your loyalty?
4

Understanding the cyclicality and external drivers of a business-such as interest rates or market volatility-helps you avoid over-extrapolating good times and prepares you for inevitable downturns.

Reflection Questions:

  • • Which key external variables (rates, regulations, demand cycles) most influence the outcomes of your investments or projects?
  • • How could you stress-test your current plans or portfolio against a scenario where those external conditions turn sharply against you?
  • • What practical safeguards-like conservative balance sheets, diversified income streams, or contingency plans-could you implement in the next six months to better handle adverse cycles?
5

Product-led growth, where customers come for a superior offering rather than aggressive marketing, can be a powerful signal of quality and a more efficient way to scale.

Reflection Questions:

  • • Where in your work are you relying more on promotion than on improving the underlying product or service itself?
  • • How might your growth trajectory change if you invested disproportionately in product quality and user outcomes instead of advertising?
  • • What is one concrete improvement you can deliver in the next 90 days that would make your product or service compelling enough for existing users to refer others organically?
6

Sizing positions or commitments according to both conviction and uncertainty allows you to benefit from upside while preserving flexibility to add more if conditions become more favorable.

Reflection Questions:

  • • Looking at your current bets (financial or otherwise), where have you overcommitted relative to your true conviction and understanding of the downside?
  • • How could you structure your next major decision so that your initial stake is meaningful but leaves room to increase or decrease it as new information emerges?
  • • What is one existing position or project you could consciously resize in the coming month to better reflect its risk, potential, and your confidence level?

Episode Summary - Notes by Skylar

TIP768: Best Quality Stock Idea Q4 2025 w/ Clay Finck
0:00 0:00